My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark XX
[0] This is exactly right.
[1] And welcome to my favorite murder.
[2] The minisode, where we read you your stories.
[3] Sometimes on video.
[4] That's right.
[5] We're on video right now for the fan cult.
[6] Check it out at my favorite murder .com.
[7] Yeah, if you want to see how red my face gets just during the day for reasons, no one can explain, join the fan cult and watch these videos.
[8] We're good salespeople.
[9] Right?
[10] We know it's going to draw people in.
[11] That's right.
[12] Oh, you want to go first?
[13] Sure.
[14] I'm not going to read you the whole thing, but this is the topic request that never ends.
[15] To my queens, fiends, and everyone in between.
[16] Buckle in because this one is a doozy.
[17] When I was a junior at the University of Iowa, says, go hawks.
[18] I was at Mickey's Irish pub in downtown Iowa City for a late -night beer during Halloween weekend.
[19] Picture racy costumes, low lighting, Mo Bamba playing way too loud, and the smell of sweat and burnt popcorn.
[20] All well enclosed in this packed as head.
[21] Hell, hole in the wall bar.
[22] Sweat and burnt popcorn.
[23] That really paints a picture.
[24] Yeah, and like stale beer too.
[25] And just loud, shouting small talk.
[26] Yeah.
[27] Well, at the bar ordering drinks, I look over and there is my pre -med, beautiful, hot -ass crush, standing right next to me also ordering drinks.
[28] Courage, fed by alcohol, consumed prior in the night, told me that this was the moment to make a move.
[29] After a flirty, oh, hey, cowboy, and then it says, It's Halloween in Iowa.
[30] Cowboy costumes are a given.
[31] We start chatting it up.
[32] Things were going great except for this drunk guy behind me, who I felt like kept trying to grab my cross -body purse.
[33] When he would move away, my purse would follow.
[34] Confident and not wanting to break away from this conversation for even a second, I grabbed the base of my purse and pulled exceptionally hard.
[35] Something ripped, something fell, and a drunk guy yelled, I'm free.
[36] Our conversation started to wane when I began really aggressively coughing.
[37] Pre -med haughty also began aggressively coughing.
[38] Many people around us also began really aggressively coughing.
[39] And then I heard the bartender scream, all caps.
[40] Pepper spray, everyone out of the bar now.
[41] Turns out drunk I was not trying to steal my purse, but rather was stuck on my pepper spray bottle that conveniently hung on the outside of my purse.
[42] And when I pulled really hard, he pulled really hard because when I looked at the ground, there she was.
[43] My beautiful, but dazzled pepper spray bottle was laying in pieces oozing orange liquid.
[44] Dude.
[45] Mickey's ended up having to close down the bar for the rest of the night to clean and pre -med haughty went home with someone else.
[46] Yeah, he did.
[47] Sad.
[48] Stay sexy and put your mace in your bag at crowded bars, BGA.
[49] Yes, BGA.
[50] Please.
[51] What?
[52] God damn it.
[53] They're like, we're finally going to make our quote on Halloween night.
[54] We're going to sell all the shitty beer.
[55] Oh, I need the Tip so I can pay rent.
[56] No. Someone had to dangle their bear spray outside of their purse.
[57] Come on.
[58] Be a team player.
[59] Okay.
[60] Oh, I like this one.
[61] The subject line is, yes, you have a listener from Iran.
[62] Oh.
[63] And then it says a near -death protesting story.
[64] Dear Karen, Georgia, and all the kind people and creatures in the world.
[65] Wow, everybody.
[66] Everyone.
[67] I was listening to Episode 349 while driving to work on a sad snowy day and suddenly heard you talking about what's happening in Iran.
[68] For a moment, my heart melted and I started to cry.
[69] So I started writing this email the moment I got to work.
[70] Exclamation point.
[71] Now that you know about what's going in Iran, boy, do I have a story for you.
[72] About two months ago, my boyfriend and I went to the ceremony for the 40th day of the death of one of the protesters, whose name was Masa Mogui.
[73] And she was only 18 when she got killed by Iran's regime.
[74] We were protesting along a big highway on the other side of the cemetery.
[75] I saw this video.
[76] We may have talked about this video.
[77] It's unbelievable.
[78] There's just the government said that they could not demonstrate or whatever because on the 40th day after someone dies, you do like, I guess, a procession to where they're buried.
[79] And it was like everybody.
[80] I mean, it was just tens of thousands of people going down this road.
[81] So we were protesting along a big highway on the other side of the cemetery.
[82] Everything was as usual.
[83] And then parentheses it says, yeah, the protesting, the death of young people is a normal thing.
[84] Sarcasm.
[85] Then for a moment, I saw thousands of people running in the opposite direction of where we were all going.
[86] I got confused, but all I was trying to do was not lose my boyfriend and keep my calm.
[87] So we decided to slowly follow the people to the highway and not run.
[88] Half of the way I felt the tear gas in the air, and with the fucked up lungs that I have, I simply just could not walk anymore.
[89] So I looked up and saw no one on the highway.
[90] From those, thousands of people literally no one was left.
[91] I panicked and looked back to see about 50 police with guns.
[92] aiming at me from about 20 meters away.
[93] For a second, I was looking at the one in front of me and I can clearly remember the look in his face and a demon in his eyes.
[94] I thought to myself, well, this is probably the end for me here and just did not want to die while looking in that man's eyes.
[95] So I slowly turned to see my boyfriend literally on the highway with a tire in his hands walking and looking for something on the ground.
[96] He didn't even see the police coming.
[97] So I shouted his name.
[98] And when he saw the police, he ran towards me, grabbed my hands, and we ran all the way to the other side to join the protesters.
[99] All these moments, I was convinced, and then it says in all caps, we are going to get shot.
[100] I just accepted my fate and was thinking about my mom and how her heart will break with my death.
[101] I do not know what happened and what stopped them from shooting us, but it was all a miracle.
[102] But not all the people were as lucky is us.
[103] Later that day, a woman got shot and died in that same ceremony we attended.
[104] Story short, I did not learn my lesson, and we still keep.
[105] keep protesting anytime we can.
[106] I'm sorry if the email was long and sorry for my bad English.
[107] I started listening to your podcast to improve my English, oh no, and have been in love with it ever since.
[108] Thank you for what you are doing every day and caring about others with love, Pari.
[109] And then she did hashtag Masa Amini, hashtag women life freedom, and hashtag stop execution in Iran.
[110] Oh my God.
[111] That's someone that is on the front lines.
[112] It's like during this revolution.
[113] It's unbelievable.
[114] Thank you, Pari.
[115] That is so powerful.
[116] How terrifying.
[117] That whole country is standing up against that regime.
[118] I mean, seeing those videos, there's lots of it on TikTok, which is so cool that you can actually kind of check in that way.
[119] And it's incredible.
[120] Karen, you know I'm all about vintage shopping.
[121] Absolutely.
[122] And when you say vintage, you mean when you physically drive to a store and actually purchase something with cash.
[123] Exactly.
[124] And if you're a small business owner, you might know Shopify is great for online sales.
[125] But did you know that they also power in -person sales?
[126] That's right.
[127] Shopify is the sound of selling everywhere, online, in store, on social media, and beyond.
[128] Give your point -of -sale system a serious upgrade with Shopify.
[129] From accepting payments to managing inventory, they have everything you need to sell in person.
[130] So give your point -of -sale system a serious upgrade with Shopify.
[131] Their sleek, reliable POS hardware takes every major payment method and looks fabulous at the same time.
[132] With Shopify, we have a powerful partner for managing our sales, and if you're a business owner, you can too.
[133] Connect with customers in line and online.
[134] Do retail right with Shopify.
[135] Sign up for a $1 per month trial period at Shopify .com slash murder.
[136] Important note, that promo code is all lowercase.
[137] Go to Shopify .com slash murder to take your retail business to the next level today.
[138] That's Shopify .com slash murder.
[139] Goodbye.
[140] Mafia poodle.
[141] Howdy, I was just listening to Minnesota 311 where you told a story about a little boy who returned Sam Giancana's lost dog.
[142] I immediately had to pause the Minnesota and write you because I knew I would forget to send this in otherwise.
[143] Thank you, ADHD.
[144] Anyways, did you ask for more mafia dog stories?
[145] No. Well, here you go anyways.
[146] You're welcome.
[147] Background.
[148] My grandpa Bill was a character who had a number of bizarre exploits both legal and otherwise.
[149] Despite all of Bill's pursuits, he was a pretty good father to my dad, who while growing up was generally kept away from anything too salacious.
[150] However, Bill did introduce my dad to a couple of his more colorful friends.
[151] This story is about one of Bill's friends, Albert Obie Fraboda.
[152] As a child, my dad had the pleasure of visiting Obie's swanky downtown apartment.
[153] He recalls sitting at the kitchen counter where Obie's wife fed him ice cream, while Obie and Bill chatted.
[154] By the end of his first visit, Obie had even gifted my dad, his first set of golf clubs.
[155] Years later, my dad stumbled across Obie's obituary in the Chicago Tribune.
[156] The obituary clarified that Obie was not, in fact, one of my grandpa's normal gambling buddies.
[157] No, Obie was actually an original member of the infamous 42 gang and a known Chicago hitman and enforcer.
[158] In addition to that little murdery chestnut, the obituary recalled the single instance where Obie had cooperated with the police.
[159] When in 1967, two young thugs mugged Obie and stole his beloved companion, a gray toy poodle named Susie.
[160] In need of assistance, a sheepish and bruised Obie called the police under an alias.
[161] Responding to the call, officers arrived at the hospital where Obie was recovering to take a statement.
[162] Evidently, the officers didn't recognize Obie from any of his 45 arrests, conviction as a bank robber, nor from the six different murders for which he had been a suspect.
[163] Shit.
[164] He must have had one of those faces.
[165] Anyways, the officers were so obliging that they went as far as allowing OV to jump in the squad car for a ride along so they could look for poor Susie.
[166] Unfortunately, the officers didn't find Susie, and subsequently, an underworld manhunt began in an effort to capture and likely dispose of the dognappers.
[167] Yeah, I bet.
[168] I can only assume that the muggers literally shit themselves when they realized whose poodle they had purloined.
[169] Regrettably, I don't know if Odie and Susie were ever reunited.
[170] However, given Obie's rap sheet, I wouldn't be surprised if the muggers responsible met a premature demise.
[171] Stay sexy and don't kidnap Mafia poodles, Tori.
[172] I mean, so dangerous, so dangerous.
[173] That idea that he's like, well, I need help finding my dog, but then it's very shameful to have been dog -napped.
[174] Yeah, I didn't know that shit went on back then.
[175] I mean, it's eternal.
[176] Everybody wants other people's dogs.
[177] Yeah.
[178] I'm not going to reach you the subject line of this.
[179] It just starts, hello, badass boss ladies, and all MFM -E -R staff.
[180] You accompanied me on many a road trip when I was catching up on episodes, and now you join me for morning coffee every Monday and Thursday.
[181] I'm here for all of it, and I thank you for what you've created.
[182] I wrote in years ago, but no dice.
[183] Alas, I'll give it another go and hope for the best.
[184] I love it.
[185] Go to real poet here.
[186] When I was 16, maybe 15, I was beyond thrilled to get my first job outside of babysitting as a clerk at a video rental store.
[187] Oh, what a rad job.
[188] Just fucking legendary.
[189] And then it's all caps, dream job at that age.
[190] I don't feel that old, but I realize as I reference a video store that maybe I am, sigh.
[191] One fateful Friday evening, the store was packed with moms and kids picking out the latest titles to entertain them for the weekend.
[192] Such a specific vibe that will never exist again in our...
[193] You'll never understand.
[194] Just like trying to figure out if you can get your mom to buy you, like, red vines.
[195] Right.
[196] Or like those greasy, single packages of popcorn, microwaveable popcorn.
[197] Yeah.
[198] Like, come on, we make it a night.
[199] Yeah.
[200] It'll be so fun.
[201] I need goobers.
[202] Isn't that a candy?
[203] Yeah.
[204] That is a very movie theater -specific candy, too, like goobers and snow caps.
[205] Yes.
[206] Mm -hmm.
[207] I was working the register, and there was a steady stream of customers at the counter.
[208] Suddenly, the air started to look a bit hazy.
[209] Then, more so, an odd smell became faintly present.
[210] The customers were oblivious.
[211] I looked at a co -worker and asked, is that smoke?
[212] He looked up, looked around, sniffed, and said, yeah, I think it is.
[213] I think there's a fire in here.
[214] Calm.
[215] Teenagers in charge.
[216] Oh, Jesus.
[217] It quickly became very obvious that there was a fire in the store, as the space between the shelves and the ceiling was now dense with smoke.
[218] Insanely, none of the customers seemed to notice and were still casually browsing the aisles, corraling their kids away from the candy and standing in line to check out.
[219] I was dumbstruck.
[220] Despite my fledgling self -confidence as a teenager in a store full of adults, I pulled it together and loudly announced, folks, the store is on fire.
[221] Please exit immediately.
[222] A few customers left, but most of them just looked around like, huh, what?
[223] But my movies.
[224] As my coworker called 911, several customers remained in line, and insisted I checked them out before exiting the building.
[225] Come on.
[226] They got to have fucking dirty dancing for that weekend.
[227] One after another, they pleaded, can't you just ring me out quickly?
[228] Finally, I could hear the fire truck nearing and I made the decision that a few DVDs and VHS tapes weren't worth the rising panic I was experiencing.
[229] Not sure why I hadn't fucked politeness earlier, I resigned myself to their apparently vital need for these films and called out, just take them, take them for free.
[230] I'm not checking anyone else out.
[231] Just get your movies and get out of the store.
[232] A few hesitated as if not paying for the rental was a bridge too far, but somehow staying in a burning building was perfectly fine.
[233] As I moved to the exit, it seemed to hit home for them that standing in a checkout line with no clerk behind the desk was pointless.
[234] I held the door to make sure everyone was out, then pieced out myself right as the fire trucks pulled in.
[235] From the parking lot, I could see the flames of the fire piercing through the center of the roof and roaring just under the shingles.
[236] It was like an attic fire.
[237] Holy shit.
[238] The firemen and women made quick work of those flames and now safely out of the building with no one hurt.
[239] I had all the drama my little teenage heart could handle.
[240] Turns out it was an electrical fire in the wiring above the false ceiling.
[241] We spent weeks mitigating the store with orange smelling special cleaner only to have the same issue occur again on reopening nights.
[242] Thankfully I wasn't working that night, and the store closed for good after that.
[243] To this day, I cannot understand what made those customers choose video rentals over safety.
[244] Was this some kind of group thanks situation?
[245] Or possibly do people want to feel safe so badly that they will deny the danger they can see and smell right in front of them?
[246] Whatever it is, this wasn't the only emergency situation I've experienced where others seem to dismiss or downplay the severity of the situation for far longer than is reasonable.
[247] Anyway, stay sexy and remember, renting a movie isn't worth smoke inhalation, even if it is the new Harry Potter, Kate.
[248] Holy shit.
[249] Yeah, teenagers in charge.
[250] Also, I think it is that thing if you want people to get out of like the store.
[251] One person has to just be definitive and like, this is what's happening.
[252] The idea that they're just leaving employees to like figure out what the emergency route is going to be for everybody.
[253] Like, what the hell?
[254] Oh, my God, terrifying.
[255] Ring an alarm.
[256] This is called Hidden Trazier, a small birthday surprise.
[257] Hello, all.
[258] I've always enjoyed a hidden treasure story, and so I thought I would submit mine.
[259] Last year on our birthday, my twin brother and I went thrifting at our favorite local thrift store.
[260] It's a place called Sharehouse in Ann Arbor, Michigan.
[261] I love that city.
[262] And it is a thrift store, but is also a nonprofit, and all their proceeds go towards helping unhoused individuals.
[263] They have everything you could ever need.
[264] Vintage clothes, Georgia, looking at you.
[265] furniture, decorations, toys, and tons of knickknacks you never knew you needed.
[266] Interestingly, there are no prices on the items.
[267] The staff chooses a price when you are checking out, and you have the opportunity to negotiate a bit.
[268] It's quite fun, and all their prices are extremely reasonable.
[269] During our trip, we'd peruse the entire store, usually not looking for anything in particular, but letting divine intervention lead the way.
[270] I was looking at some hanging sweatshirts and noticed a little pink envelope sticking out of a hoodie pocket.
[271] Intrigued, I investigated, and initially I thought it was just a price tag until I pulled it out and inside there was $20 with an old note that read, this is a random act of kindness.
[272] Today is my birthday and I wanted to spread some joy and happiness, so please spend this $20 on whatever you like.
[273] I was tickled.
[274] It was so generous and I was so grateful, especially because it was our birthday too.
[275] I used the $20 to purchase my brother a little bird cage and I bought myself some shoes.
[276] The kindness of a stranger really had an impact because I told everyone about it.
[277] That is my hidden treasure story.
[278] This upcoming year for our birthday, my brother and I are planning on leaving little envelopes at our favorite places in hopes that it will brighten someone's day.
[279] Nice.
[280] Stay sexy and leave hidden treasure for people to find.
[281] And then it says M is her name.
[282] And then it says, Ann Grant, who's not a listener yet.
[283] Grant, get over here.
[284] That's actually a really lovely thing to do for your own birthday.
[285] Yeah.
[286] It's like doing something generous and practicing generosity, actually, is a lovely gift to oneself.
[287] Totally.
[288] All right.
[289] Here's my last one.
[290] Here we go.
[291] I'm not going to read the subject line.
[292] It says, hey, gals, this is the best story, and I cannot believe I didn't remember it until now.
[293] Way back in the late 80s, when my very cool twin aunts, Katie and Susie, were in their 20s.
[294] They were hanging out at home on Saturday night doing the things that people did at the time before the internet.
[295] Susie was downstairs in the living room reading a book, and Katie was upstairs in a room.
[296] As Susie was reading, she heard rustling in the kitchen, then a clank of metal.
[297] She knew that sound very well.
[298] It was the top of their pastry dish lifting off of its platter.
[299] Susie was furious.
[300] She had told Katie not to touch her cupcakes as she made them for a friend's housewarming party.
[301] Susie slammed her book down and ran into the kitchen to confront her sister.
[302] Katie do not fucking touch those cupcakes.
[303] But as soon as she entered the kitchen, a man, dressed in all black, gingerly holding the pastry top.
[304] Susie terrified and only wearing a t -shirt and cotton undies, was stunned still.
[305] As she tells it, it was the power of her dead father channeling through her that eventually yelled, get the fuck out of my house.
[306] Then the terrified would -be thief, dropped the pastry top onto the floor and ran out the back door.
[307] There was a moment of silence, and then Susie heard Katie from upstairs.
[308] Would you shut up about those cupcakes?
[309] It's now a story told fondly at family gatherings, but Susie still says how baffled she is that she fully yelled at the robber.
[310] Luckily, she's never had to test her skills with would -be thieves again.
[311] Thanks for reading, and I look forward to no doubt hearing this thrilling tale on the air, much love, Rosie.
[312] You're right, Rosie.
[313] Good job.
[314] All right, everyone send us your stories at my favorite murder at Gmail, and you could be about anything at this point.
[315] We support you.
[316] We support your storytelling.
[317] We know you're going to do a good job.
[318] Stay sexy.
[319] And don't get murdered.
[320] Goodbye.
[321] Elvis, do you want a cookie?
[322] This has been an exactly right production.
[323] Our senior producer is Hannah Kyle Kreiton.
[324] Our producer is Alejandra Keck.
[325] This episode was engineered and mixed by Stephen Ray Morris.
[326] Our researchers are Marin McClashen and Sarah Blair Jenkins.
[327] Email your hometowns and fucking hoorays to my favorite murder at gmail .com.
[328] Follow the show on Instagram and Facebook.
[329] at My Favorite Murder and Twitter at My Fave Murder.
[330] Goodbye.
[331] Follow My Favorite Murder on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you like to listen so you don't miss an episode.
[332] If you like what you hear, rate and review the show.
[333] Visit exactly right store .com to purchase my favorite murder merch.